Welcome to PaulFranklin.ca
The official website of Paul Franklin: a father, veteran, activist, motivational speaker, and proud Canadian.

Sunday, March 31, 2013

Here are two articles that best showcase that the truth is sometimes not from an American perspective and not a Canadian perspective but a Afghan perspective.




    
People who had suffered the most during the war against terror in Afghanistan are undoubtedly the citizens, the villagers who had nothing to do with terrorism. They suffered at the hands of militants who want to take over their country and at the hands of those who are seeking to oust the terrorists. Their country, Afghanistan has been labeled as a terrorist country and the innocent Afghans are paying for it in one way or another.
ANA watching Panjawai


For almost eleven years the people of Afghanistan suffered, hoping that one day the war against terror would come to an end and they’d be able to live their lives peacefully, the way they lived before, but nothing happened. Now, in the past few months things have changed a little bit. Afghans are now standing up against the Taliban insurgents on their own.

The uprising in the district of Panjwai stands out because it is the first in southern Afghanistan which is the spiritual heartland of the Taliban movement. It is a huge accomplishment because it is a region where the militants thrived despite N.A.T.O. and American operations. It is being considered as the most significant uprising against the Taliban.

taliban
Reuters

It began in February when the villagers along with police forces began the revolt in this region which is known for its rich vineyards and orchards. The Panjwai Uprising is also a very good example of how the government and its people can stand together in the face of adversity and accomplish great things for the country. According to a report, almost hundred village elders have vowed to keep fighting against the militants on Monday. The Taliban have vowed to return but the villagers are ready to face them when they do.

The Taliban were laying mines in the orchards. Villagers weren’t aware of the location of the mines and would only know when someone got killed. The people are fed up of all the terrorism and deaths. They want to get rid of this mess. So, theyhave joined the government forces to oust these terrorists who have destroyed the peace of their country. These people are a brilliant example of the fact that they have the courage to fight for their country even if they lose their lives doing so.

The Panjwai uprising will forever be remembered as an effort the common man of Afghanistan made to restore peace. It is something that must be respected, appreciated and encouraged in each and every way. They would be the people who will hopefully create a new image of the war-plagued country: a new tolerant and peaceful Afghanistan.



Despite the uprising the Americans still hold to the belief that Canada failed in its mission, the Afghans and of course the Canadians disagree

WASHINGTON—American reluctance to confront Canada over its weak military hold in the Taliban heartland of Kandahar province was among the costlier blunders of the war in Afghanistan, a new book alleges.

 Excerpts published Friday by The Washington Post describe the rising concerns of a team of U.S. military advisers who were stunned in 2009 when an unnamed senior Canadian intelligence official in Kandahar told them, “I have no idea what’s going on inside the city.”
 
The sheer thinness of Canadian boots in Kandahar — only 2,830 soldiers, mostly assigned to headquarters and support roles, with fewer than 600 going on patrol — contrasted against more than 9,000 British soldiers deployed in the less populated and less strategically important neighbouring province of Helmand, Washington Post senior correspondent Rajiv Chandrasekaran writes in Little America: The War Within the War for Afghanistan.
 
But when the U.S. reassessment team returned to Kabul to learn why more Canadians had not been deployed, they were told by the U.S. Maj.-Gen. Michael Tucker, then the director of operations for all NATO troops, “It is wrong to tell a (Canadian) commander, from this level, to put troops in Kandahar city.”
 
Sitting next to Tucker in that Kabul meeting was Andrew Exum, an influential counterinsurgency strategist and former Army Ranger platoon leader, battle-hardened by earlier deployments to Iraq and Afghanistan.
 
Exum’s notes from that Kabul encounter are excoriating. “This guy is a jackass,” Exum wrote of Tucker’s hesitance to direct the Canadians. “Kandahar — not Helmand — is the single point of failure in Afghanistan.”
 
When Exum and his reassessment team investigated further, the book alleges, they were told by U.S. Army Brig.-Gen. John “Mick” Nicholson, that the Americans were reluctant to ruffle feathers in Ottawa.
 
“(Nicholson) emphasized that the Kandahar mission was Canada’s largest overseas deployment since the Korean War. Military leaders in Ottawa were reluctant to ask for more help — some were convinced that security in Kandahar was improving, others didn’t want to risk the embarrassment,” writes Chandrasekaran.
On patrol
“To Exum and others on the team, however, it seemed that U.S. commanders thought that managing the NATO alliance was more important than winning the war.”
 
Exum, a fellow with the Washington-based Center for a New American Security, was brought on as part of a group of outside advisers convened by Gen. Stanley McChrystal when he was appointed the top commander in Afghanistan in 2009.
 

But the Americans had their own reasons for wanting to avoid Kandahar at the outset of the Obama administration, Chandrasekaran writes in Little America, which is based on more than 70 interviews with U.S. government and military officials directly involved in Afghan war policy. 

Foremost among them was the Pentagon’s own struggles in locating senior troop commanders willing to dispatch thousands of additional forces to Afghanistan after so many years of rolling deployment to the region.
 
One of the few with a “zeal for Afghanistan” was Marine Corps Commandant Gen. James Conway. But Conway “drove a hard bargain” with his Pentagon counterparts, insisting that any fresh Marine deployment must involve “a contiguous area” where the U.S. Marines would wield total control, including support from Marine helicopters and supply convoys.
 
“These stipulations effectively excluded Kandahar,” writes Chandrasekaran. “The geography of the province, and the Canadians’ desire to hold on to the key districts around Kandahar city, made it nearly impossible to carve out a Marine-only area there.
 
“Helmand was the next best option, even if it was less vital.”
 
By that time, the Canadian military had already asked for help in Kandahar province, although the number of reinforcements requested was still small compared to the presence in Helmand province.


 
In January 2008, an independent panel led by former Liberal deputy prime minister John Manley issued a report recommending that Canada extend its mission in Afghanistan beyond February 2009, on the condition that NATO deploy a battle group of about 1,000 additional soldiers to back up Canadian troops in Kandahar.
 
The report also called on the Canadian government to provide troops with surveillance drones and large helicopters as another condition for extending the mission.
 
Canada managed to secure those extra troops – and thereby meets its conditions for extending the mission to 2011 – when the United States committed to sending 1,000 soldiers to the southern province after France decided to join the war efforts.
 
The Americans took control of Kandahar City in 2010 following a decision by U.S. President Barack Obama to flood southern Afghanistan with troops.
 
Canadians troops were left in charge of Panjawai, Dand and Daman districts until Canada ended its combat mission there in July 2011.
 

Panjawai
A spokesman for Defence Minister Peter MacKay responded to the allegations by praising the work of Canadian troops in Afghanistan.
 
“Canada has played a leadership role in the UN-mandated, NATO-led mission in Afghanistan, both through the previous combat mission in Kandahar and our current training mission centred in Kabul. Working alongside our international partners, our Canadian Forces personnel have made tangible strides to improve the lives of the Afghan people, and have made great progress in helping them to increase their nation’s safety and security,” MacKay’s press secretary, Joshua Zanin, wrote in an emailed statement on Friday.
 
With files from Joanna Smith
Foremost among them was the Pentagon’s own struggles in locating senior troop commanders willing to dispatch thousands of additional forces to Afghanistan after so many years of rolling deployment to the region.
 
One of the few with a “zeal for Afghanistan” was Marine Corps Commandant Gen. James Conway. But Conway “drove a hard bargain” with his Pentagon counterparts, insisting that any fresh Marine deployment must involve “a contiguous area” where the U.S. Marines would wield total control, including support from Marine helicopters and supply convoys.
 
“These stipulations effectively excluded Kandahar,” writes Chandrasekaran. “The geography of the province, and the Canadians’ desire to hold on to the key districts around Kandahar city, made it nearly impossible to carve out a Marine-only area there.
 
“Helmand was the next best option, even if it was less vital.”
 
By that time, the Canadian military had already asked for help in Kandahar province, although the number of reinforcements requested was still small compared to the presence in Helmand province.
 
In January 2008, an independent panel led by former Liberal deputy prime minister John Manley issued a report recommending that Canada extend its mission in Afghanistan beyond February 2009, on the condition that NATO deploy a battle group of about 1,000 additional soldiers to back up Canadian troops in Kandahar.
 
The report also called on the Canadian government to provide troops with surveillance drones and large helicopters as another condition for extending the mission.
 
Canada managed to secure those extra troops – and thereby meets its conditions for extending the mission to 2011 – when the United States committed to sending 1,000 soldiers to the southern province after France decided to join the war efforts.
 
The Americans took control of Kandahar City in 2010 following a decision by U.S. President Barack Obama to flood southern Afghanistan with troops.
 
Canadians troops were left in charge of Panjawai, Dand and Daman districts until Canada ended its combat mission there in July 2011.
Panjawai Road
 
A spokesman for Defence Minister Peter MacKay responded to the allegations by praising the work of Canadian troops in Afghanistan.
 
“Canada has played a leadership role in the UN-mandated, NATO-led mission in Afghanistan, both through the previous combat mission in Kandahar and our current training mission centred in Kabul. Working alongside our international partners, our Canadian Forces personnel have made tangible strides to improve the lives of the Afghan people, and have made great progress in helping them to increase their nation’s safety and security,” MacKay’s press secretary, Joshua Zanin, wrote in an emailed statement on Friday.
 
With files from Joanna Smith

16 comments:

  1. ptsd counselling Edmonton

    Best Counselling & Mental Health in Edmonton. Counselor provides counseling services for Anger, trauma, depression anxiety, addiction, marriage and parenting counselling. Edmonton Counselling offering unique counselling, supporting individuals, couples & families. Making our community a better place. Online Booking


    to get more - https://edmontoncounsellingservices.ca/

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi Dear,

    I really prefer your blog..! This blog are very useful for me and other. So I see it every day.

    We offer private " PTSD counselling Edmonton " for individaul, couples and family. Our experienced psycotherapist provide counseling for anxiety, marriage and depression etc.

    Visit Now - https://edmontoncounsellingservices.ca/

    ReplyDelete
  3. Tort Law Assignment Help in the field of law, alludes to a lawful screw up which instigates a complainant to suffer harm or injury, coming full circle in lawful obligation regarding the individual submitting a tortious demonstration. This may incorporate intentional enthusiastic injury inconvenience, disregard, budgetary misfortunes, wounds, the break of security, and a few different things.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Agency and freelance escorts you should spend your time with those fabulous women. Typically, Greater Kailash escorts have a freelance and escorts agency. Attention and trustworthiness are very important for escorts. company office Howeverials augment you with a thorough background record check of escorts, to make sure that you are not worried about the security half. For this you do not panic once visiting our Greater Kailash escorts agency See of
    Greater Kailash escorts

    ReplyDelete
  5. Delhi Call Girls Agency, we are one among the various escort organization providing food young ladies for sexual administrations in Delhi and NCR. Our administrations are expanded all over Delhi and edges. We keep up unmistakable class of young ladies at all the majority of noticeable districts of the Delhi to guarantee our customers immediate and wanted administrations. Our Call Girls in Delhi are best class of young ladies giving extreme joy and furthermore moving message to not to surrender except if you achieve your point. Our Escort Service in Delhi attempt to change viewpoint towards life however yes they show the procedures to appreciate life and grin against the odd of life. Likewise become familiar with the procedures to make meeting more acceptable and interesting with escort young ladies.

    ReplyDelete

  6. 3D Architectural Design || 3D Architectural Design company
    Quickgunz Pvt Ltd is the finest 3D Architectural Design company provider company in India. We create 3D Architectural designs which can easily be visualized on the laptops or computer screens. This Company has a team of expert 3D designers who develop 3D aerial view, 3D walk through, 3D Buildings,3d apartment, 3d township, Business Park,highways,and many more 3D Architectural Designs.
    3D Architectural Design Company
    3D Architectural Design Company In India

    ReplyDelete
  7. Constitutional Law Assignment Help the student should be fully aware of all the legal clauses and nuances. So it becomes a little difficult for many students to keep up with their assignments as many of them are not so aware of the entire legal clause.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Nice to see your write up that provide me the best information about the LogisticGuru, the professional Car Transport Mumbai . Thanks for sharing the post. Apart from the good car transportation service, they offer the service like Warehouse, Insurance and Road Survey on their customers' demands that ensure entire stress-free car transportation service. Visit their website; it is well designed where you can get lots of information.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Grab effective Computer Network Assignment Help if you don’t find right support to finish your projects. For more information, visit greatassignmenthelp.com and get the instant solution for your queries.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Hello , I discovered Your Blog is Amazing . As A substance Writter You Explained Very Well In this . I took in alsot From Your Website . I Read Your Blog and I might Want to Suggest You To Read This Blog Bellsouth.Net Email Login Also. I doubtlessly accept that you will like it .

    ReplyDelete
  11. south indian silk sarees for wedding In this article, we will give indications of best wedding silk and cotton made saree's dresses for 2022. The assortment is organized by contemporary guidelines in Indian, Bangladeshi, Sri Lankan, and Pakistani societies.traditional south indian silk sarees

    ReplyDelete
  12. south indian silk sarees for weddingIndia is a force to be reckoned with of arranged kinds of textures and henceforth, native sarees. Each locale of India has heaps of remarkable fashioner sarees, well known for their extravagance and hand-woven styles. Essentially, South Indian sarees including Kanchipuram silk sarees, wedding pattu sarees, Dharmavaram silk sarees and handloom printed silk sarees are viewed as the native part of relish among the ladies.
    traditional south indian silk sarees

    ReplyDelete
  13. To Withdraw Crypto From Kraken To Trust Wallet, follow these steps: 1. Open Trust Wallet. 2. Select the cryptocurrency you want to withdraw. 3. Tap on "Receive" to obtain your wallet address. 4. Go to Kraken, initiate the withdrawal, and enter the Trust Wallet address. 5. Confirm the transaction.

    ReplyDelete